National News: National Geographic
"Blood Ivory: Elephants in Crisis" by Bryan Christy

With a
shocking title and an emotion-tugging introduction paragraph, Christy does an
excellent job of catching the attention of his readers and reeling them in to
the story. The first line of the title, “Blood Ivory,” immediately tells the
reader that this story is about the needless slaughter of elephants without
having to read on to the second line. The image of blood, in this case when associated
with animals, is a powerful visual that speaks for itself—especially when the
readers of National Geographic care
greatly about animals and the environment. The writer does a great job of
snagging the hearts of his target audience. The introduction paragraph takes
hold of shocking, violent phrases, which is apparent in sentences like “From
the air too the scattered bodies present a senseless crime scene—you can see
which animals fled, which mothers tried to protect their young, how one
terrified herd of 50 went down together.” Christy knows that his readers will
care about the condition of the African elephant species and therefore uses the
most gut-wrenching adjectives and descriptions in order to invoke the extreme
sense of sympathy that National Geographic
is aiming for.
Shocking
the reader with sad and gruesome imagery is not Christy’s only talent. The journalist
spins a long tale about the over-active, illegal ivory trade and makes sure to
back up his claims with a variety of important sources. Christy investigates
several different perpetrators around the world, making sure to get the full
back story behind each. The statistics he uses are important in pushing his
argument, and with numbered data like “5.4 tons of illegal ivory (was) seized
by customs agents in Manila in 2009, 7.7 tons seized there in 2005, and 6.1
tons bound for the Philippines seized by Taiwan in 2006. Assuming an average of
22 pounds of ivory per elephant, these seizures represent about 1,745
elephants.” Christy’s digits add up to an impressive, as well as depressing,
corpse of facts. Turning the numbers into animals really gets the readers heart
pumping as it puts the context into a visual that is inescapable.

Christy
also makes sure he takes the images of the suspects involved with the illegal
ivory trade and makes them appear, in some way, evil. For instance, Christy’s
first subject, Monsignor Cristobal Garcia, is described as a religious fanatic
who spends lavish amounts of money on ivory statues and whose obsession (as
well as his church’s followers’ obsession) over religious sculptures borders on
cult insanity. Christy regales Garcia’s dark past in hope to sway the reader
against him, mentioning how Garcia “while serving as a priest at St. Dominic’s
of Los Angeles, California, sexually abused an altar boy in his early teens and
was dismissed.” With the obvious agenda of dressing up Garcia as a villain,
Christy points out the perfect flaws. The journalist does an equally good job
denouncing Father Jay in his next segment on the “Catholic-Muslim Underground.”
He quotes the priest’s opinions of
the intense amount of ivory bought and sold by the Vatican and the statements
are effectively shocking. In one moment of the interview, Father Jay makes a
statement about the excessive use of ivory in holy statues that reads “’I don’t
call it extravagant…I call it an offering to God.’” Even more shocking, the
writer captures the seedy underbelly of the Church by connecting it to illegal
trade. Christy imprisons this phenomenon when he asks about all of the fresh
ivory items that have been flowing through the Church. Jay says, “’They come in
through the back door.’ In other words, they’re smuggled. ‘…You buy the ivory,
which came from a hazy origin, and you turn it into a spiritual item. See?’ he
says, with a giggle. His voice lowers to a whisper. ‘Because it’s like buying a
stolen item.’” How more villainous can you get?
Christy even manages to get Garcia
and a few other important figure heads to disclose their preferred ways of
smuggling ivory. The orders are revealed in surprising detail and the process
is mostly splayed out for the reader. This information is revealing a deeper
glimpse into the trade, the horrors behind it, and the lengths that traders and
consumers will go to for their products to be bought. Christy also includes a
handful of other prominent religious figures from different countries and even
brings up the issue of China’s ivory factories. Covering a very vast range of
sources and giving great detail, Christy forms a compelling and believable
argument, supported by a slew of heart-gripping pictures that further invest
the readers’ emotions. Also included on the website are maps, videos, alternative related articles, and other useful information regarding the case. As always, good job National
Geographic.
Original article and the pictures used within my analysis can be found here:
http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2012/10/ivory/christy-text