Tuesday, October 16, 2012

Undead Girl

Local News: Washington Missourian 

On "Missing Washington Girl Found Alive in Ravine," by Ed Pruneau



            I have mixed feelings about this article. I found no major fault in the way it was written. It is short and to the point without unneeded, fabricated elaboration. Unlike most tragedy stories, especially in small town news where the slightest drama is extravagantly exciting, the author avoids graphic adjectives and steers away from overemphasis. There is even a link within the text that takes the reader to an interview with the runaway’s mother. There is also an embedded video interview with the sheriff involved in the case. The reader can take advantage of both of these links and get a fuller picture of the story. These are examples of good sourcing and provide extra outlets for the audience to further delve into the story. As a free standing article, I believe Pruneau did a good job in his construction of the piece. It is what happened during the actual investigation that baffles and offends me.
            Pruneau reports that “The searchers initially reported that they could not detect a pulse and there were no signs of life, the sheriff’s office reported. Sheriff Gary Toelke said he first notified the parents that their daughter had been found, but she was deceased.” Police officials are not supposed to be able to pronounce a victim as deceased. That is a paramedic or EMT’s job. An ambulance should be called even if the cop in charge believes the subject to be dead. A social servant with an actual medical license is the only person with the authority to pronounce a person deceased. I found it entertaining that Toelke was quoted saying how “in his years in law enforcement he could not recall a situation when a person was pronounced dead and then found to be alive.” Of course he would say such a thing—he would not want to appear to be a faulty social servant. The author does a good job of remaining unbiased and just relays facts. But through the facts given, it is easy to infer the neglect on the lead investigator’s part.
 
http://www.emissourian.com/news/top_stories/article_a8c0c7d8-13b8-11e2-a2b8-0019bb2963f4.html

No comments:

Post a Comment