Tuesday, September 18, 2012

A Meaty Lawsuit

National News: "ABC News sued for defamation over 'pink slime,'"

by Candice Choi




This article caught my attention because it gives a perfect example of the repercussions of writing (and speaking) a defaming piece of news, from utterance to backtalk. Here, the company Beef Products is suing ABC for the misrepresentation and slander of their product. The article explains how Beef Products will have to prove the intent of actual malice on part of ABC in order to win the trial, a true and important piece of information.
It is a very well written article in terms of structure and substance. The author even explains the history behind where the name “pink slime” came from, the coiner of which is mentioned as a defendant in the case, labeled slanderer by Beef Products (the accuser). Choi goes so far as to name the number of pages that the lawsuit contains and exactly who the main defendants were. Good statistics are also given, such as, “Craig Letch, BPI's director of food-quality assurance, said the company lost 80 percent of its business in 28 days.” The sources are high-ranking and the quotes are solid, adding impressive evidence to the article.
When interviews or reliable information could not be obtained, that was noted as well. An example of such a statement is, “Richard McIntire, a spokesman for the USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service, declined to comment and attempts to reach Foshee were unsuccessful.” Two major organizations failed to respond to the situation, which looks dramatic and is a whole lot better than omitting their silence. Another example includes, "I'm just a scientist giving my opinion. I'm not going to deal with this nonsense," he said, referring questions to his attorney.” These serve as good reference stock for an already loaded arsenal.
On a side note, I do wonder where the unrelated reference to ABC ownership came from in the line “ABC News, owned by The Walt Disney Co., denied BPI's claims.” The author seems to be pointing a finger, but the motive remains unclear.


http://entertainment.channelone.com/ap/BPI-sues-ABC-News-for-%27pink-slime%27-defamation-56937185-fm
 

No comments:

Post a Comment