Wednesday, August 29, 2012

Middle Class Mirror

Local news: The St. Louis Post Dispatch

"Share of Middle Class Income Shrinking"

The annual income of the middle class is, according to Hope Yen, dwindling. Her article describes the fall of the “middle class” and how they do not earn as much money as they did in the 1970’s. While true, the decline of such income percentages is shallow and the margin of error erases half the statistic. She uses information from the Census Bureau to prove valid her accusation. According to the data, the middle class, “makes up about 51% of U.S. adults, down from 61% in 1971.” While valid information, the drop in the number of middle class individuals does not seem steep enough for alarm when paired with the provided (at the VERY end of the article) with the margin of error, which was 3.9.
Another cause for alarm rose. Again, toward the final thoughts of the piece, a new statistic rears its head. According to Yen, “Median net worth for the middle class fell 28% over the last decade…Lower-income families saw net worth fall 45%.” Why is there an article about the middle class’s decline and not the lower-income’s decline, if theirs is so much greater? The answer lies in the consumer. The majority of people that have $2.00 to throw down on a newspaper or the incentive to research articles from it online are not lower-income citizens. Therefore, the majority of readers would rather see an article about the middle class than the lower class.
Furthermore, the only directly quoted individual (not organization) is Timothy Smeeding, a professor of economics at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. While economics does relate to the article completely, what’s failed to be mentioned is that Smeeding himself fits into the provided middle class criteria of making up to $118,255 a year. This turns Smeeding’s viewpoint into normative economics. A quote from the professor; “There are the disaffected middle class who work hard and play by the rules of society, but increasingly see their situation declining by forces beyond their control.” Earning a middle class income, Smeeding’s bias opinion holds no solidity in a factual article. On top of everything, the article has four bulleted “findings” that present themselves as factual evidence but are, in fact, just results of polls conducted by an unknown source.

No comments:

Post a Comment